Vanicream Lotion VS Cream: Which One Is Best For You?

Last Updated on May 18, 2025 by Giorgia Guazzarotti

If you’ve ever wandered through the skincare aisle looking for something gentle enough for super sensitive skin ) but still, you know, actually works) you’ve probably seen Vanicream. It’s one of those dermatologist-loved brands that keeps it simple, no fuss, and (blessedly) fragrance-free. But then comes the moment of truth: do you get the lotion or the cream? They look almost the same, but they’re not. Let’s break it down. Vanicream Lotion VS Cream: which one is right for your skin type? Which will give YOU best results?

Key Ingredients In Vanicream Lotion VS Cream

Take a look at the ingredient list and you’ll find these formulations are pretty much identical. The key difference? They have the same ingredients in slightly different order. That’s means it’s the concentrations of ingredients that’s different. For example, the cream has more petrolatum, which makes it heavier and more occlusive. Think: more of a barrier that really seals everything in. It also has a lot less water.

Even more important is what’s NOT in them. No dyes, no fragrance, no harsh preservatives, no essential oils. None of the usual culprits that can irritate skin. So what is in them? Here are all the ingredients and what they do for your skin:

• Water: The main solvent in the products, it dissolves other ingredients. The lotion makes a point to say the water has been purified, so I’m guessing the water in the cream has not been. Purified simply means the impurities in the water that could spoil the formula have been removed. 
• Petrolatum: It has a bad rep because it comes from crude oil, but it’s actually super safe. The kind used in skincare is purified to remove all toxic impurities. In reality, it’s one of the safest, most effective occlusives out there. It forms a protective barrier on your skin that locks in moisture to prevent water loss. So nope, petrolatum isn’t the villain it’s made out to be. And if you’re wondering, how can it gentler than natural ingredients well… it doesn’t contain any of pollen, resins, or fragrant components natural ingredients often have. There you have it.
• Sorbitol: A humectant that helps skin retain more water. It also gives slip to a product.
• Cetearyl alcohol: One of the main fatty alcohols, it makes skin softer and smoother. It also enhances the texture of the product.
• Propylene glycol: It acts as a humectant, a fancy way of saying it attracts and binds water to the skin to deeply hydrated it. Plus. it helps deliver active ingredients into your skin.
• Ceteareth-20: A fatty alcohol that keeps the ingredients in a formula well-mixed together.
• Simethicone: A type of silicones that stop skincare products from foaming – when that’s not needed (I mean, these aren’t cleansers!).
• Glyceryl stearate: it makes skin softer and smoother and keeps the ingredients well-blended together.
• PEG-30 stearate: Another emulsifier that keeps the ingredients well-blended together.
• Sorbic acid: A gentle preservative that inhibits the growth of bacteria, fungi, and other crap in your skincare products.
• BHT: Another preservative that keeps your skincare products safe from harm.

Does this mean you won’t experience an allergic reaction? Well, there are people who are allergic to water, so a patch test is always in order. Said that, this is a very gentle formulation unlikely to cause side effects (unless misused). 

Stop wasting your time and money on stuff that doesn’t work. Click on the image below to download “Skincare That Works” and finally get your best skin day – every day.

What Is The Texture Like?

This is where you’ll actually FEEL the difference.

• The lotion is light, smooth, and sinks in fast without leaving any greasy leftovers and no sticky face. It’s the kind of product you throw on without thinking, especially if it’s hot out or you’re layering under makeup. A lighter version of Vanicream Moisturizing Cream, this is your go-to lightweight lotion for everyday hydration.
• The cream, on the other hand, is thick and buttery. It takes its time to sink in, but that’s the point. If your skin’s dry, tight, or throwing a full-on tantrum? This one wraps it up like a soft blanket and tells it to chill. It helps relieve itchy skin, too. 

Think of the lotion as your everyday tee. The cream? That’s your oversized fleece hoodie when the heating’s broken.

What Is The Packaging Like?

Nothing fancy – and honestly, that’s the point.

• The lotion comes in a basic plastic bottle with a pump. Super easy, super clean, and great if you’re on the go or just don’t want to fuss.
• The cream usually shows up in a big ol’ tub. Classic, no-frills, and made for scooping. Some versions now come in a pump too, if tubs aren’t your thing. It needs to be in this kind of packaging. The texture’s too thick to flow easily out of a tube.

If you’ve got long nails or just can’t be bothered with dipping your fingers into a jar, the lotion’s your low-effort friend. But if you’re all about that rich, heavy hydration? The tub’s worth the scoop.

How To Use Them

There’s no complicated 7-step ritual here.

• Use the lotion after showering or washing your face, morning or night. Layer it under other products or use on its own. It’s a great option for daily facial use that gives your skin a normal moisture level without feeling heavy.
• Use the cream when your skin feels extra dry or after retinoids, peels, or cold weather exposure. It’s great as a nighttime occlusive layer too. If your skin’s as dry as the Sahara (mine is), slather it on every day. Everyone else? This is more for that winter itch or when your skin needs some extra TLC, not daily use.

Pro tip: If you’re using actives like tretinoin, Vanicream Cream makes a stellar buffer to reduce irritation.

Can You Use Them On Your Face?

Yup. Neither is just a body lotion. Both are techniclally non-comedogenic (aka they won’t clog pores), so you can use them head to toe. I say technically because petrolatum traps whatever you previous applied under its protective barrier. So if your serum has comedogenic ingredients, you may still breakout. Just be careful there! Said that, the lotion works great under makeup. The cream might be too heavy for daytime face use unless your skin is super dry or you’re healing from something harsh.

Are They Safe for Eczema or Sensitive Skin?

Both are accepted by the National Eczema Association, so if your skin throws tantrums at every new product, these are some of the safest bets you can make. It’s petroleum that helps with this. Curious to know how? Simple. Petroleum creates a protective barrier on the skin that keeps germs, pollutants, and other skin enemies from actually touching your skin, thus  lowering the risk of infection. It also helps wounds heal faster by preventing germs from entering open sores and cracked, sensitive skin. And of course, it increases skin’s moisture, which is what eczema and sensitive skin badly need.

How Do They Compare To CeraVe Moisturizing Cream?

If Vanicream is plain toast, CeraVe is toast with butter and a sprinkle of something extra. Both are fragrance-free, both are great for sensitive skin, but CeraVe gentle moisturizer just brings more to the table. It’s got key ceramides, which help repair your skin barrier (you know, that thing that’s probably been wrecked by retinoids, peels, or winter), and hyaluronic acid, which pulls moisture into your skin and keeps it there. Vanicream skin cream mostly sits on top and protects. CeraVe treats and protects. 

I still think Vanicream is brilliant when your skin is throwing a tantrum and you need to keep it simple. But on a regular day? I always reach for CeraVe Moisturizing Cream.  So if your skin barrier needs a hug and a repair crew? CeraVe’s the one. P.S. I use the cream for my body and CeraVe PM on my face (it’s light weight and my moist recommended product to my clients, no matter what skin type or skin conditions they have). 

Price & Availability

Vanicream Moisturizing Lotion: $18.99 at Ulta

Vanicream Moisturizing Cream: $20.99 at Ulta

So, Which One Should You Go For?

Choose Vanicream Moisturising Lotion if:

• You have oily, combo, or acne-prone skin.
• You need something lightweight for everyday use.
• You hate sticky or greasy finishes.

Choose Vanicream Moisturizing Skin Cream if:

• Your skin is dry, sensitive, or easily irritated.
• You’re dealing with eczema, barrier damage, or winter skin.
• You want that “slugging” effect without using straight-up Vaseline.

Or honestly? Keep both on hand. Lotion for the daytime, cream for night. Lotion for summer, cream for winter. Lotion for face, cream for body. You get the idea.

The Bottom Line

If your skin could talk, it’d probably thank you for choosing Vanicream products – either one. They’re both great products. No trendy marketing, no perfume party, no mystery irritants. Just plain old moisture that actually does its job. Can I have an amen? But if you’re still torn on the best option for you? Here’s the cheat sheet:

• Oily skin, combination skin, lightweight feel? The lotion is a great addition to your daily routine. 
• Dry skin, barrier SOS? The cream is the ideal formula for this.