What’s the Best All Good Sunscreen? I Tested Them All

Last Updated on May 24, 2025 by Giorgia Guazzarotti

Sunscreen is a non-negotiable, that much is clear. But with so many options out there, how do you know which one’s really worth your time and money? All Good Sunscreen has been getting a lot of attention lately, so I decided to take a closer look. Is it really as “all good” as the name suggests, or is it just another product that’s all talk?

In this All Good Sunscreen review, we’re breaking down everything from how it feels on your skin to how well it actually protects you from the sun. Does it leave a weird residue on top of your skin? Is it too thick? Is it even worth switching from your usual go-to? Keep reading, because we’re diving into all the details you need to know before you decide if this sunscreen’s right for you.

The Benefits Of All Good Sunscreens

I can’t start an All Good Sunscreen review without talking about what’s the deal with this brand. Why is everyone raving about it?

1. All Good sunscreens only use ONE UV filter, non-nano zinc oxide: This UV filter protects, on its own, from the entire UV range. Compare that to chemical sunscreens, which usually protects from either UVA or UVB rays – and so you need to use a bunch of them together to get the job done. FYI, in case you’re wondering, both physical sunscreens and chemical sunscreens work the same way. They absorb UV light and turn it into heat, which is less damaging to the body. BUT, zinc oxide is much gentler on the skin and rarely causes irritations. The only downside? It leaves an unpleasant white cast – especially in the high concentrations used here (I mean, if it’s the only ingredient in the formula, it must have a huge dollop, know what I’m saying?)
2. Won’t damage coral reefs: We have zinc oxide to thank for this too. While some chemical UV filters (oxybenzone and octinoxate, I’m looking at you) have been shown to bleach coral reefs and disrupt marine ecosystems, non-nano zinc oxide is one of this reef-friendly ingredients that’s safe for marine life. Plus, the formulas are very simple and don’t contain any unnecessary ingredients.
3. Botanical ingredients: All Good sunscreens have very short ingredient lists. Heck, some formulas have only zinc oxide and a handful of natural ingredients to protect and moisturise skin. No extra fillers that do nothing – and could irritate skin. 

Now you know what’s special about them, let’s review them one by one, shall we?

Stop wasting your time and money on stuff that doesn’t work. Click on the image below to download “Skincare That Works” and finally get your best skin day – every day.

All Good SPF30 Sport Mineral Sunscreen Lotion ($18.00)

The Sport Sunscreen Lotion is a no-nonsense sunscreen with ingredients that actually do something good for your skin. The non-nano zinc oxide protects against UV rays, while aloe vera juice helps hydrate and calm your skin. Shea butter and coconut oil bring in some moisture, and sunflower and olive oils keep skin soft and nourished. You’ve also got a little antioxidant boost thanks to green tea and rose hip. Every little bit helps to keep wrinkles from making an early appearance. It’s water-resistant, which makes it great for outdoor activities, and a little goes a long way. One small dab covers a lot. Did I mention it hydrates your skin for hours? The only catch: it leaves a white cast, even on pale skin. But if you’re cool with that, this one’s easily a top pick for me.

All Good Mineral Sunstick SPF30 ($11.00)

All Good Sport Mineral Sunscreen Stick SPF30 is seriously a game-changer. First of all, the mess-free stick is everything. You literally just glide it over your skin. No fuss, no spills. It’s perfect for the face or quick touch-ups during the day. It’s packed with zinc oxide (20%), which gives you solid sun protection without the irritation, and it works really well against UVA and UVB rays. More surprisingly, it doesn’t even leave your skin feeling greasy. Plus, coconut and jojoba oils make it super hydrating for your skin. In case you’re wondering, yes it leaves a white cast on the skin, so you have to pat it in carefully. Seriously, this stick sunscreen is so handy to have in your bag, especially during the summer when you need quick, no-mess sun protection. It’s one of those products you’ll end up using all the time.

All Good SPF50 Kids Mineral Sunscreen Butter Stick ($18.00)

The All Good SPF50 Kids Mineral Sunscreen Butter Stick is perfect if you want something quick and easy for your kids. It’s got 25% zinc oxide, so you know it’s doing the job to protect their sensitive skin from the sun. The formula’s got calming calendula and chamomile, plus coconut and jojoba oils to keep their skin hydrated without feeling greasy. And Vitamin E helps with skin protection, too. Best part? It’s a stick, so no mess at all. Just swipe it on and you’re good to go. It’s super simple, no fuss, just protection that works and is safe for their sensitive skin. It leaves a white cast – but hey, at least you’ll know when it’s time to reapply it on your little ones.

All Good SPF30 Kids Mineral Sunscreen Lotion ($18.00)

The All Good SPF30 Kids Mineral Sunscreen Lotion is great if you want something that works but isn’t full of harsh stuff. It’s got 16% zinc oxide for solid sun protection, so you know your kid’s skin is covered. Aloe, calendula, and chamomile soothe any potential irritations – just in case you missed a spot (although it leaves a white cast, so you’ll notice that).Coconut oil and shea butter make it hydrating too. It rubs in easily and doesn’t leave that heavy, oily feel. Perfect for a day out in the sun without any of the mess. Just a simple, effective sunscreen that gets the job done for daily use.

All Good SPF30 Kids Mineral Sunscreen Spray ($21.00)

The All Good SPF30 Kids Mineral Sunscreen Spray is decent if you want quick sun protection. It’s got 14% zinc oxide, so it does the job blocking the sun. Aloe, calendula, and chamomile calm the skin, and coconut oil and safflower oil keep it hydrated, but not greasy. That said, I’m not a fan of spray sunscreens. They’re clear, so you can easily miss a huge chunk of skin. You think you’re protected – next thing you know, you get a sunburn. I personally recommend you avoid spray sunscreens. But if you must use it, take a little extra care when spraying.

All Good Mineral Sunstick SPF30 – Coconut ($11.00)

The Mineral Sunstick SPF30 – Coconut is perfect if you want easy, no-mess sunscreen. It’s got 20% zinc oxide, so you know you’re protected from the sun. It goes on smooth, and the coconut oil and jojoba oil keep your skin hydrated without making it greasy. It even smells nice, but not like you’re slathering on a coconut perfume. Shea butter and cocoa butter give it that extra bit of nourishment, while the beeswax and carnauba wax make sure it stays on. It’s a stick, so you can swipe it on quickly and be on your way (well, after blending it in, so the white cast disappears). Simple as that.

All Good Sport Mineral Sport Sunscreen Butter Tinted ($10.00)

If the white cast’s putting you off, this is the formula to reach out for. This butter sunscreen is tinted, so it dries clear and matte on your skin. Ok, maybe not super clear. The tint’s way too dark for a pale skin tone, but for most women, you won’t notice after you slather it on. The formula itself is lovely. It has 25% zinc oxide to provide full spectrum protection, while the moisturising base (coconut and jojoba oils) keep skin soft and smooth in the sun. Did I mention it also give you water-resistant protection for up to 80 minutes? The tin makes the sunscreen easy to carry with you everywhere – just use it carefully. This stuff doesn’t have preservative and you don’t want any nasties to accidentally make it into the tin.

All Good SPF30 Tinted Mineral Sunscreen ($20.00)

This is another good option if you want to avoid looking like Caspar The Ghost and are not a fan of tin cans (I mean, it’s a cool idea, but this is sunscreen, not tuna). Another mineral-based sunscreen with 25% non-nano zinc oxide, it offers excellent protection as well as water resistance for up to 80 minutes. The rest of the formula is made up of moisturising butters and antioxidants. The only thing is the tint isn’t suitable for pale skin. It’s too dark for us, ladies. But if it matches your skin, this is worth checking out.

All Good SPF 50 Tinted Mineral Sunscreen Butter ($11.00)

This one’s a great option if you’re over the ghostly look that comes with most mineral sunscreens. With 25% non-nano zinc oxide, it gives you SPF 50 protection and dries to a barely-there matte finish even combination skin will love. The tinted formula helps blend in without leaving a white cast (but it’s too dark for pale skin). The moisturizing butters and oils keep your skin soft, although it’s too heavy for oily skin. If you’re spending all day at the beach, you can count on this to keep you safe (as long as you apply enough!). Just make sure no nasties get into that tin!

​All Good SPF50 Sport Mineral Sunscreen Butter Stick ($18.00)

This little stick is a beach bag MVP. It’s got 25% non-nano zinc oxide (aka solid protection), glides on like a lip balm for your face, ears, shoulders (wherever you need it) and stays put, even if you’re sweaty or swimming. No mess, no white cast (as long as you rub it in), and it won’t leak all over your stuff. Perfect for quick reapplications when you’re out all day. Just don’t expect it to cover your whole body – this is a swipe-and-go situation, not a slather.

Availability

All Good Sunscreens are available on their website: https://allgoodbodycare.com/

The Bottom Line

After testing pretty much everything in the All Good sunscreen lineup – from the classic lotion to the tinted butter stick to the sport stick – here’s the deal: this brand creates safe sunscreens that get the job done without irritating your skin Every formula uses non-nano zinc oxide for broad spectrum protection, skips the junk extras, and leans into organic ingredients like shea butter and plant oils. They’re not fancy. They’re not trendy. But in this All Good sunscreen review, the verdict is clear: they’re solid, dependable, and actually good for your skin. If you’re looking for a clean, no-fuss mineral sunscreen that works, All Good is a safe bet. Just pick the version that fits your vibe – and don’t forget to reapply.