Affiliate Links

Last Updated on March 16, 2026 by Giorgia Guazzarotti

the best eye makeup removers

Are you struggling to find the right eye makeup remover? If it’s too gentle, it won’t take off anything – unless you tug and pull for 10 minutes. If it’s too harsh, it stings up real bad. And if you go down the oil route, you get a blurred vision for a couple of minutes. What’s a girl to do, give up mascara?! I don’t know about you, but I’m not ready for that. Instead, I’ve done the hard work for you. I’ve tried plenty over the years, and been disappointed more times than I can count. But in the end, I’ve managed to find a few gems. Here they are, they best eye makeup remover for your every need:

1. Best Multi-Tasking Eye Makeup Remover: Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover For Lids, Lashes, & Lips ($28.00)

Can’t be bothered to use a makeup remover for your eyes and another for your lips? Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover for Lids, Lashes & Lips got you covered. This dual-phase remover takes off both longwearing lipsticks and waterproof mascaras in just a couple of swipes. Yet, it’s very gentle on the skin and does’t irritate your eyes. It’s a staple in my stash.

Available at: Look Fantastic, Sephora, Nordstrom, and Ulta

2. Best Eye Makeup Remover For Sensitive Skin: Paula’s Choice Gentle Touch Makeup Remover ($24.00)

Paula’s Choice Gentle Touch Makeup Remover can be used all over the face, eyes included. I don’t know about you, but I love to use just one product and be done with it. What makes this one special is the inclusion of soothing ingredients, like Aloe vera and allantoin. They soothe your skin as the makeup remover takes every last trace of long wearing foundation, and waterproof makeup off your skin.

Available at: Paula’s Choice

Related: The Complete Guide To Aloe Vera In Skincare: Can It Soothe Irritations, Hydrate Skin And Treat Stretch Marks?

Want to get the most out of your skincare products? Click on the image below to subscribe to my newsletter and receive the “How To Combine Actives Like A Pro” cheatsheet.

3. Best Eye Makeup Remover For Dry Skin: Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover ($7.99)

If you prefer an eye makeup remover in lotion form that hydrates skin while it removes makeup, get your hands on Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover. True to its name, it removes even stubborn waterproof makeup while leaving your skin softer and hydrated. Shake its gently to activate the formula and then use a cotton pad to gently swipe everything off your lid. There’s not much else to say. It works.

Available at: Target

4. Best Eye Makeup Remover On A Buget: L’Oreal Clean Artiste Waterproof & Long Wearing Eye Makeup Remover ($7.99)

One of the cheapest eye makeup removers at the drugstore, L’Oreal Clean Artiste Waterproof & Long Wearing Eye Makeup Remover is as effective as it’s gentle. Free of fragrance and other irritants, it removes all traces of makeup (including waterproof mascaras) without irritating the delicate eye area. If you’re on a budget, this is the one to get.

Available at: Target and Ulta

5. Best Natural Makeup Remover: Jojoba Oil

Want to keep your skincare routine as natural as possible? Cleanse with oils. Oils work because like attracts like. Natural oils attach to the oils in your makeup, melting them away. You can use almost any oils for this, but Jojoba is my fave. Why? For starters, it has a lightweight texture that doesn’t leave a greasy mess everywhere. It doesn’t have a strong scent that may irritate the eye area. And it takes everything off.

Available at: Your local health food shops.

Related: What’s The Oil Cleansing Method And Should You Use It?

FAQs

How do I use an oil like jojoba to remove eye makeup?

Massage a few drops onto dry lids with dry fingertips – water deactivates the oil’s ability to grab onto makeup. Give it 20-30 seconds to dissolve everything, then wipe away with a damp cotton pad. Follow with your regular cleanser. That second cleanse isn’t optional: skip it and you’re going to bed with a film of dissolved mascara and oil on your skin, which is a fast track to milia and congested pores. Dual-phase removers like the Clinique don’t need a follow-up cleanse, which is part of why they’re so convenient.

Does it matter how long you leave the remover on before wiping?

Yes, and most people skip this step entirely. Press a soaked pad onto your closed lid for 20-30 seconds before moving it. This lets the formula dissolve the makeup so you do less physical work. It matters most with waterproof mascara – the less you scrub, the fewer lashes end up on the cotton pad.

Does it matter what I use to wipe – cotton pad, reusable pad, or cotton swab?

A regular cotton pad works fine for the lid and lash line. For the corners and lower lash line, a cotton swab is more precise and less likely to drag product across your undereye. Reusable pads are a perfectly good alternative, as long as they’re soft – anything with texture is too rough for the eye area. Whatever you use, press first, then slide once in one direction outward, away from the inner corner. No back-and-forth.

Should I press and hold or swipe – and does direction matter?

Press and hold first, always, then one slow outward swipe. The skin around your eyes is the thinnest on your face and has almost no underlying fat or collagen support. Repeated dragging in multiple directions just leads to wrinkles overtime. Be kind!

Do I need to remove my contact lenses before using eye makeup remover?

Yes, always remove your lenses first. Most eye makeup removers contain emulsifiers, silicones, or oils that can absorb into soft contact lenses and cause irritation, blurred vision, or damage to the lens itself. Even gentle formulas aren’t designed to interact with contacts. Lenses out first, then remove your makeup.

Can I use these removers if I have eyelash extensions?

Oil is the enemy of lash extension adhesive. Straight oils like jojoba are out entirely, and so is the Clinique Take The Day Off, which contains ingredients that can weaken the bond over time. Your safest bet is a water-based or gel formula specifically labelled as extension-safe. Of the products listed here, the Paula’s Choice Gentle Touch is the closest to appropriate, but formulas and adhesives vary – check with your lash tech before using anything new.

The Bottom Line

Finding the right eye makeup remover is genuinely trial and error. What works brilliantly for your friend with dry skin and zero eye sensitivity might leave you red-eyed and irritated by morning. But once you find your formula, technique matters just as much as the product itself. Be patient with it, press before you swipe, and resist the urge to scrub. Your future lids will thank you.

And if you’re not ready to give up waterproof mascara, same. Just know that removing it properly doesn’t have to be a 10-minute ordeal. With the right approach, it takes less than a minute and your skin stays intact. That’s a trade worth making.